Friday, May 30, 2025

Handicapper's Corner: 2025 Arlington Stakes (G3)

Turf stars seeking green in Arlington Stakes

By: John Caro, ThoroFan Handicapper

Churchill is featuring a multi-stakes day on Saturday with five graded stakes and a black type in alternating dirt and turf surfaces. We’re looking to capitalise on the Arlington (G3). Weather should be good; however, rain is in the forecast for Friday and may impact the lawn races.

We have several horses who have recently raced against each other except #7 Silent Heart, who’s been racing at Gulfstream since last fall. Except for Silent Heart, all have seen each other in a race at some point in their careers, and every one of today’s runners is familiar with Churchill’s lawn. Some with great success, so let’s start there.

#9 Brilliant Berti – DeVaux/Hernandez, BJ - Four for four at Churchill and 6 for 9 on the grass. A $1.8M winner on turf. 2 for 3 at the distance. Has beaten half of the remaining eight horses in today’s field, and none have beaten him. And he is third off a layoff...Hard not to like. Top contender.

#5 Lagynos – Asmussen/Prat – Just missed against Brilliant Berti above going a mile here on May 1. The video shows a good battle between them in the stretch. Part has taken this horse into the money 3 times with one win. He is a stalwart runner, and he is also on a third time out after a layoff. Must use ITM and exotics.

#8 Mercante – Knippenberg/Ramos JD – You may not be familiar with the trainer, but, he has entered 9 races this year and is winning at 56% and 67% ITM. JD Ramos missed by 3/4 of winning the Grade I Turf Classic here on a good turf going longer. I think he likes the artificial surface best, but he can show his talent on the grass as well, going ITM 5 of five attempts. Dangerous to leave off your tickets.

I see the above as your top contenders and below are the longshots that could very well upset or make you exotics bloom.

#6 Call Protection – Maker/Ortiz, I. Jr – Maker sends his charge out after winning a 100K optional, claiming race by 2 & 1/2 going a mile and an eighth a month ago in near record time, 1:45.52 going through traffic. He’s two for three on the grass. Maker has upgraded his jockey choice, in my opinion. The win above came on a firm turf going 98 Bris speed. That may well do it. If he runs like last out and makes a mile in the lead at 1:33, he could crush the field. My top longshot and must play in exotics.

#3 Gigante  - Asmussen/Ortiz JL – He was in the Turf Classic here earlier in the month along with Mercante, and he took the lead in the backstretch as the jockey saw the pace as too slow, I guess. Held on until the final eight and then gave in. Jockey change to a guy who has won with this horse two for three. If you look at the PPs, this is a horse who has steady speed throughout usually tracking the pace. Grinders get the job done when nobody is watching them. Another dangerous horse. ITM.

#7 Silent Heart  - Lynch/Saez – He has not faced any of these before. In his last 10 races, he has only missed the money twice. He was third by a neck to a fine horse at Gulfstream, Fort Washington. Does his best racing when he is close to the pace and applies his middle space speed. He could be the speed of the race. Half to use him.

#4 Herchee – Pitts/Morales  - Brilliant speed in his first race back since the fall, winning at the distance against 12 others at Keeneland. Morales being his exclusive rider is a plus. His tracking style, middle-pace figures and times between the calls show a horse that has matured and is ready to do something special. I can’t not put him in the mix.

The Others

#1 Event Detail – Walden/Rosario  - He finished second behind the very hot pace from Call Protection above. Likes to be a late closer, but he has too many others here that can do that faster.

#2 Cameo Performance  -  Walsh/Curtis  - Wasn’t able to keep up the pace in the Turf Classic last out and got lost in the crowd.

Handigambling….. Let’s not go crazy since there are 5 other stakes races to go Saturday.

$2 Trifecta      $30

9 with 5, 6, 8 with 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8

$2 Exacta       $24

5, 6, 8, 9 with 3, 4, 7

Win bets on 3, 4, 7…..You choose how much based on the odds

Bonus bet

$1 Pick 3 Race 9-11    $8

9, 6, 3, 4 with 3, 6  with 2

 

Saturday, May 24, 2025

Handicapper's Corner: 2025 Santa Margarita (G2)

 The heat is on in Santa Margarita Stakes

By: Laurie Ross, Pedigree Power


The $200,000 Grade 2 Santa Margarita at Santa Anita attracted a small competitive field of six older fillies and mares on Sunday’s card.

Formerly a Grade 1 contest, the Santa Margarita list of winners includes Zenyatta and her sister Balance, Life is Sweet, Nashoba’s Key and Adare Manor, who captured the last two editions of the 1 1/8 mile event.

The Santa Margarita is featured as race 3 of 10 with a post time of 2:05 PM PT.

Let’s review the field.

Liberal Lady returns to Santa Anita, where she has a 7-2-0-1 record. She’s been hit-or-miss against lesser types but can press the pace. The Leonard Powell trainee is up against better fillies, and her Brisnet late-pace figures are some of the lowest in the Santa Margarita, but if she settles a few lengths off a hot pace, she has a shot to light up the exotics.

The lightly raced Princess of Time has only four starts under her girth. This 5-year-old didn’t make it to the races until last April when she was off slow and bumped in a turf maiden race. MIA until this January, the Mike McCarthy trainee bested maidens by 2 1/2 lengths at six furlongs. Princess of Time did the same in her next start, then was third against optional claimers at a mile. While her Brisnet ratings are competitive, Princess of Time adds distance, faces more experienced foes, and will be challenged on the front end. Pass.

Where’s My Ring scratched from the Gamely (G1) for a more suitable spot on the dirt. She’s coming off a third-place finish in the Apple Blossom (G1) and captured the 1 1/8 mile Gazelle (G3) last year. She was off until this March when she bested optional claimers at Oaklawn. Now she’s making her first start for Peter Miller, who has 2 winners from 16 starters after a trainer switch. Both winners were turf sprinter – milers. Where’s My Ring has tactical speed and can settle off the just off the pace. She’s also one of two in here with a victory at 1 1/8 miles. Contender.

Splendora has faced better in her quest for a graded win. She was second to Kopion in last year’s La Brea (G1) and fourth behind that rival in the Santa Monica (G2). Kopion ran away with the  Derby City Distaff (G1) in her last start and is one of the top sprinters in the country.

The Bob Baffert trainee chased Richi (Chi) in the Santa Maria (G2) in her last start. Splendora earned a career-best 105 Brisnet speed rating in her last start, and her late-pace figures are the best in the field. She’s only won on the lead, but she has plenty of early zip, having set a 12.56 first quarter in her second start. Baffert captured the last two editions of the Santa Margarita with Adare Manor. While Splendora isn’t in that one’s league, she could run this group off their feet – if she can carry her speed. Contender.

Alpha Bella scratched from the Gamely (G1). She hasn’t won since January 2024, when she captured the 1 1/2 mile La Prevoyante (G3) over the Gulfstream lawn. The John Sadler trainee is consistently in the money against Grade two and Grade 3 types on dirt, and switches back to dirt after a one-length loss in the Wilshire (G3). John Sadler has a 34% win rate with this angle, but 59% of his charges hit the board. Alpha Bella only wins while on the lead; otherwise, she’s a solid exotics play.

When she has the lead, Seismic Beauty is unstoppable. She captured her second start last year by five lengths after dueling through quick early fractions. Bob Baffert’s charge didn’t get the lead in her next pair of starts against optional claimers and was green down the lane. Once straightened out, she had every opportunity but stayed behind the pacesetter.

In her second start against optional claimers, Seismic Beauty broke a step slow from the rail. She rushed up but had to tap on the brakes. Down the lane, JJ Hernandez tried to push Seismic Beauty through a hole, but she didn’t want any part of that and finished a non-threatening third. The experiment ended in her last start against optional claimers, this time at a mile. Seismic Beauty broke confidently, established the lead, and won by ten lengths, as an even-money favorite should.

The question is – can Seismic Beauty carry her speed 1 1/8 miles? Uncle Mo’s daughter is out of a stakes-placed sprinter by Medaglia d’Oro, and the little blacktype in her immediate family is speed-oriented. However, her breeding suggests that Seismic Beauty can handle 1 1/8 miles. She’s a wildcard, as we don’t know how she’ll react to being challenged on the lead. Her late-pace figures are in the mid-80s, but her mid-race figures are in the 100s. Talented but quirky. Exotics.

Analysis

Five of the last 12 Santa Margarita heroines won or placed in the Santa Maria. Speed rules at Santa Anita. Five of the previous 12 winners set the pace, while the majority of the rest were pressers. Bet the favorite. None have placed worse than fourth in 12 years, and four of the last five won.

Splendora fits the historical winner’s profile. The Grade 1-placed filly has plenty of speed but is a vulnerable favorite.

Where’s My Ring has experience at 1 1/8 miles and can press the pace.

Alpha Bella is predictable and generally cashes a check.

Seismic Beauty could get the lead and run away. Otherwise, her competitive nature is questionable.

 Selections

3. Where’s My Ring (5-2)

4. Splendora (6-5)

5. Alpha Bella (5-1)

 

Friday, May 16, 2025

Handicapper's Corner: 2025 Preakness Consensus

 Who Do We Like in the Preakness?

 
 

This week, ThoroFan Handicappers share their 2025 Preakness predictions for first, second, and third place, as well as their best longshot bomb.

Shoutout to Robert Marks for nailing the exact order of the top three Derby finishers!

Good Luck to everyone and Get Your Preak On!

HANDICAPPER

FIRST

SECOND

THIRD

LONGSHOT

Michael Amo

Sandman 

Clever Again

Journalism

River Thames

John Caro

Journalism

Clever Again

Pay Billy

Gosger

Nick Costa

Sandman 

Journalism

Heart of Honor

American Promise

Suart Mark deVoe

Journalism

Clever Again

Goal Oriented

American Promise

Robert Marks

Journalism

River Thames

Clever Again

Gosger

MaryJo Moncheski

Heart of Honor

Journalism

Sandman 

Gosger

Laurie Ross

Journalism

Sandman 

Gosger

Clever Again

Rowan Ward

Journalism

Gosger

Clever Again

American Promise