Pegasus World Cup: Youth vs. Experience
Saturday’s $3 million Grade 1 Pegasus World Cup Invitational
assembles a compelling mix of lightly raced emerging talent and seasoned
veterans, anchored by defending champion White Abarrio.
A full field of 12 will go to the post, including Lightning
Tones, who drew in from the also-eligible list after Madaket Road scratched.
The group will tackle 1 1/8 miles around the Gulfstream Park oval, closing out
a blockbuster 13-race program highlighted by six additional graded stakes. Post
time for the Pegasus is 5:39 PM ET.
Let’s review the field:
Disco Time (8-5) missed last year’s Derby trail due
to injury but returned in strong fashion, posting dominant victories in the St.
Louis Derby and the listed Dwyer, once a Grade 1 and later a Grade 2. Granted,
the competition he defeated falls short of what he meets here, but the final
times were legitimate, particularly his 9 3/4-length Dwyer score in 1:33.86,
capped by a sharp 12.75 final furlong while cruising home under a hand ride.
Disco Time stretches out to 1 1/8 miles for the first time,
though his pedigree, by Not This Time out of multiple stakes winner Disco Chick
(Jump Start), suggests the distance won’t be an issue. Adding confidence, his
half-brother Bright Spark (Arrogate) won at 1 3/16 miles. Brad Cox tightened
the screws with three quick five-furlong breezes at Payson Park. Contender.
British Isles (20-1) a three-time winner from 22
starts, is more familiar with minor awards than trips to the winner’s circle.
After spending much of his career on turf, the Richard Baltas trainee pushed
Nevada Beach to the wire in the Native Diver (G3), missing by just a half-length,
with a solid 12.43 final furlong for 1 1/8 miles. On paper, that effort looks
appealing, until you dig deeper.
British Isles has historically struggled away from
California. Yes, he won once at Keeneland, but that came during his second
consecutive start there. The Justify colt also delivered the best race of his
career in the Native Diver, earning a career-best 105 Brisnet figure and a 107
late pace number, ten points higher than any prior effort. He also makes his
first start for a new barn. Maybe he surprises, but there are too many red
flags. Pass.
Full Serrano (12-1) has been ultra-consistent since
arriving in California, finishing first or second in every start and going off
at 4-1 in the Breeders’ Cup Mile. That day, he was cooked after chasing Citizen
Bull’s blistering opening quarter in 21.74 and a 44.96 half, fading to fifth.
Previously, the John Sadler trainee finished second to
Nevada Beach in the 1 1/8-mile Goodwood, earning a 102 Brisnet rating and a
career-best 106 late pace figure, and narrowly missed in the Laffit Pincay Jr.
Stakes behind Dirt Mile winner Nysos. He finds softer company here and runs
well off a layoff. Contender.
The 6-year-old Banishing (20-1) flashed quality last
spring when he missed by a neck to Mindframe in the Churchill Downs (G1). He
followed with wins against lesser company and had a legitimate excuse in the
Lukas Classic, where he was squeezed so tightly between Disarm and Mystic Dan that
Tyler Gaffalione was forced to steady. Surprising there was no inquiry, but
that’s racing.
After a poor start in the Breeders’ Cup Sprint, Banishing
rebounded with a runner-up finish in another sprint. Bred to relish added
distance and always competitive, he’s not top-tier but merits consideration in longshot
exotics.
With rare exceptions, Skippylongstocking (15-1) shows
up every time. Still holding his own at age seven, he’s traded punches with
many of these rivals and makes his fourth Pegasus appearance for Saffie Joseph
Jr. After finally hitting the board last year, a similar exotics result
feels likely.
Tappan Street (6-1) has clearly rebounded from the
injury that derailed his Triple Crown bid. The Brad Cox trainee owns the
distinction of being the only horse to defeat Sovereignty last year. Following
a workmanlike effort against optional claimers, he continued to train forwardly
at Payson Park and should improve off that return. Contender.
Poster (20-1) hasn’t beaten much but took a step
forward in the Harlan’s Holiday (G3) against Skippylongstocking. Poster
traveled wide while Skippylongstocking enjoyed a ground-saving trip, and
despite the effort, the veteran always had him measured. If they went around
again, the result likely wouldn’t change. Eoin Harty adds blinkers in search of
improvement. Longshot exotics.
Captain Cook (15-1) captured the Withers at 1 1/8
miles against lesser company but has struggled to sustain momentum around two
turns otherwise. Second in back-to-back sprints in his first two starts for
Todd Pletcher, he showed ability against Patch Adams in the H. Allen Jerkens
(G1). Despite a pair of bullet works at Palm Beach Downs, he appears better
suited to sprinting. Pass.
Mika (10-1) acquitted himself well in his graded
debut when second to Bishop’s Bay in the Cigar Mile. However, he enjoyed an
uncontested lead, opened a 2 1/2-length advantage turning for home, and still
couldn’t hold off a rival who had previously been a solid Grade 3 type. That
scenario won’t repeat here. Pass.
White Abarrio (4-1) returns to defend his crown,
though circumstances differ markedly from last year. He prepped with a
runner-up finish in the Mr. Prospector (G3) prior to his 2024 Pegasus win but
missed scheduled preps this time and was scratched from both the Mr. Prospector
and the Breeders’ Cup Classic. He hasn’t raced since August. While he fires
fresh and clearly loves Gulfstream, post 11 doesn’t help, and a repeat seems
unlikely. Pass.
On the positive side, Brotha Keny (30-1) can handle
the distance. On the negative side, he hasn’t shown he can beat Grade 3
company. He earns the title of the Pegasus “Why?” horse. Pass.
A Gulfstream mainstay, Lightning Tones (30-1)
reliably earns checks and owns two Sunshine Classic Stakes victories. Last
year, he closed mildly to finish third in the Gulfstream Park Mile (G2) and was
no match for White Abarrio in the 1 1/16-mile Ghostzapper (G3). Pass.
Analysis
Previous Starts: Most of the last 15 Pegasus winners
gained ground and finished in the top three in their prior start, with many
making their first start off a layoff. Six exited the Breeders’ Cup Mile or
Classic.
Run Style: Speed dominates. Pace pressers within two
lengths of the lead have been most effective, while pacesetters accounted for
five victories.
Favorites: Trust the chalk. Nine of the last 15
favorites finished in the top three, including three winners in the past five
editions, along with one second and one clunker.
Post Position: Inside posts hold a slight edge,
particularly post 4, which produced five winners. Posts 1, 8, and 10 yielded
two winners each, while rail runners hit the superfecta nine times.
It’s the
youngsters who returned successfully after injury vs. the old timers, most of
whom have taken turns beating each other over the years.
Disco Time hasn’t beaten much, but he’s looked the
part doing it, with improving figures and added distance in his favor.
Typically a pacesetter or presser, he also showed the ability to close through
trouble in the Lecomte and should either control or stalk the pace.
Tappan Street brings tactical speed and should move
forward in his second start off the layoff, settling just off the leaders.
Full Serrano, the 2024 Breeders’ Cup Dirt Mile
winner, routinely posts double-digit speed figures. However, the 7-year-old has
never raced outside California and hasn’t shown an ability to rate, leaving him
as a question mark.
Poster’s worst finish came on Tapeta, yet he still
completed the superfecta. A wide trip in the Harlan’s Holiday and reluctance to
pass Skippylongstocking suggest the addition of blinkers could help keep him
closer early.
For multi-ticket players, Banishing and Skippylongstocking
deserve consideration.
Banishing endured a brutal trip in the Lukas Classic and
owns tactical speed across multiple tracks, making him an intriguing longshot.
Skippylongstocking always shows up, and while he’s finished
behind several rivals in the past, consistency remains his calling card.
That leaves White Abarrio. The fan favorite loves
Gulfstream, but missed training time, scratched from his last two races, and
doesn’t arrive with the same momentum as last year. At 4-1 morning line, I’m leaving
him out of my top picks.
Selections:
7. Tappan Street (4-1)
1. Disco Time (8-5)
3. Full Serrano (12-1)
8. Poster (20-1)